Did We Stop Listening?

By Guest Blogger: Jim Baldassare
I’ve been thinking about how Republicans managed to lose the midterms so badly after entering Washington with the presidency and control of both houses of Congress. To me, much of the answer comes down to something pretty basic: they lost touch with the people who put them there.
People wanted a secure border, a more affordable life, a government that worked better, and some confidence that the country was moving in the right direction. Republicans had an opportunity to deliver. There were accomplishments worth discussing, too. But somewhere along the way, the administration became much better at announcing victories than explaining how those victories would make everyday life better.
And when people said they were still struggling, too often the response sounded like an argument about why they shouldn’t be, and to stop complaining.

Take the economy. There was good news Republicans could have built a reasonable message around. Economic growth strengthened in the third quarter, business investment improved, and private employers continued adding jobs. Those are meaningful developments.
But most people don’t measure the economy by a quarterly report. They measure it when they buy groceries, pay their insurance, fill their gas tank, or help their kids with expenses.
The president should have been able to say, “We’re making progress. Here’s where things are improving. But I know that doesn’t mean much if your bills are still stretching your paycheck, and here’s what we’re working on next.”
That would have been believable. It would also have shown that he was listening.
Instead, the administration too often talked as though a strong economic number settled the discussion. You can’t talk someone out of the financial pressure they’re experiencing.

That brings us to tariffs. I understand the argument for using them to protect important industries or gain leverage in negotiations. But there are costs, and Republicans should have been honest about them from day one and throughout. The Congressional Budget Office projected that higher tariffs would add to inflation and weigh on growth.
If you’re asking Americans to accept those costs for a larger benefit, explain the tradeoff. Tell them what you expect to accomplish, how long it might take, and how you’ll judge whether it’s working or not. You can’t campaign on affordability and then brush aside questions about policies that make some things more expensive.

Immigration was especially disappointing to me.
Securing the border was necessary, and I give the administration credit for making it a priority. But securing the border and deciding how to handle people already living here are two different responsibilities. They needed separate, clearly explained policies.
There should have been an unmistakable focus on removing dangerous criminals, with proper due process. At the same time, the president should have at least tried to work with Democrats on an earned path to legal status and eventual citizenship for people who have otherwise lived peacefully, worked hard, raised families, and contributed to this country.
That doesn’t mean ignoring immigration laws. It means recognizing that a violent offender and someone who has spent years working and supporting a family present very different circumstances.
The enforcement effort went well beyond people convicted of crimes. Research using government records found that only 27 percent of ICE arrests leading to detention in July involved people with criminal convictions. That doesn’t tell us everything about each individual case, but it raises serious questions about the priorities guiding the operation. Who is the brain surgeon in the Administration that didn’t recognize this?
People should feel safe helping law enforcement identify dangerous individuals. If someone witnesses a crime, we want that person to come forward. When entire communities become afraid of any contact with authorities, cooperation becomes harder.
I would have liked to see the president bring leaders from both parties together and say, “Surely we can agree on getting dangerous people out of this country while finding a fair, workable solution for families who are contributing.”
Would that have been easy? Of course not. But making that effort was part of the job. The way the ICE roundups were implemented squandered an opportunity to build broader support for a sensible immigration policy.

Then there was Iran.
I believe preventing Iran’s government from obtaining a nuclear weapon is a vital objective, and I believe military action can be justified toward that end. Iran’s support for terrorism, threats against our allies, and treatment of its own people are serious matters.
But when a president who promised to avoid prolonged Middle Eastern wars commits the country to another conflict, he owes Americans a continuing explanation.
People need to understand what we were trying to accomplish, what progress was being made, what could go wrong, and what a reasonable conclusion might look like. They also deserved an honest conversation about the economic consequences.
The president should have spoken regularly and plainly to the country: “I know this is costing you money. I know higher fuel prices hurt. Here is why I believe this action is necessary, and here is what we’re doing to bring the conflict to a successful conclusion and ease the burden.”
He should have sought Democratic support, too. When American service members are in harm’s way and families are absorbing the costs at home, the effort to build national unity matters.
Instead, comments minimizing higher gasoline prices as “a little glitch,” or emphasizing how much money American oil producers could make from rising prices, sent an entirely different message.
That’s a tough thing for someone to hear while watching the cost of their commute climb.
You can support a military mission and still be worried about paying your bills. A president needs to make room for both realities. He also shouldn’t promise that the hardship will be brief when nobody can confidently know that.

Infrastructure was another missed opportunity.
Most Americans would welcome a serious effort to modernize air traffic communications, strengthen the electrical grid, improve communications networks, and replace outdated government technology. These are practical investments people can understand.
To be fair, money was committed. The 2025 reconciliation law included $12.5 billion for air traffic modernization, so the criticism shouldn’t be that absolutely nothing happened. The question is what happened after the announcement.
What has been installed? What works better today? What remains unfinished, and when will it be completed? Those are the updates Americans should have been hearing regularly. Announcing funding is a start. Delivering a more reliable system is the accomplishment.
Against that backdrop, the attention given to the White House ballroom was hard to understand. The administration described the ballroom itself as privately funded, with public spending associated with security work. But even accepting that distinction, the optics were awful.
People worried about their household expenses didn’t need to hear so much enthusiasm about a presidential ballroom. They needed to see that same energy directed toward the systems they depend on every day.

Congressional Republicans have their own share of responsibility.
They did pass major legislation, including a substantial tax-and-spending law. But after years of asking voters for control of Washington, they needed to deliver more of the practical results they had promised.
Voter identification is a good example. I believe a reasonable photo identification requirement, paired with accessible identification for eligible voters, should have been something lawmakers could work out.
Yet Republicans couldn’t get an agreement across the finish line. A voter-ID amendment received 53 votes in the Senate but failed to meet the procedural threshold needed to advance. Beyond embarrassing.
I understand that controlling the Senate doesn’t automatically give you the votes to overcome a filibuster. But Republican leaders understood that, too. They needed a strategy built around the actual rules and the votes available.
That means negotiating, addressing reasonable objections, and giving the other side something it can support. You don’t have to abandon your principles to sit down with someone who disagrees with you.
The same problem showed up in the effort to shrink government.
I believe government has become too large, too expensive, and too tangled up in everyday life. There was a legitimate case for reform.
But there’s a sensible way to do it. Explain which functions are unnecessary. Identify duplication. Preserve the people with essential expertise. Show taxpayers how the changes will improve service and save money.
Instead, dismissals, resignation programs, and layoffs were followed in some instances by reversals and delays. That made the process look less carefully planned than it should have been.
And the people affected were still people—employees with families, mortgages, and years of service. You can eliminate an unnecessary position while treating the person who held it with respect.
The public needed to see thoughtful management. Too often, the approach came across as anger directed at government employees.

Running through all of this was a failure to build coalitions.
Republicans seemed too willing to treat Democratic support as something either impossible to obtain or unnecessary to pursue. Democrats have responsibilities here as well, and some would have opposed the president regardless. But the president still had the responsibility to try—and to keep trying where common ground was possible.
Border security, public safety, reliable infrastructure, effective government, and preventing a nuclear threat should all offer room for serious discussion.
Every disagreement doesn’t need to become a personal fight. Sometimes people just want to see the adults stay in the room long enough to solve something.
I don’t read this election as proof that Americans suddenly rejected every Republican idea. My view is that too many voters stopped trusting Republicans to carry those ideas out competently and with an understanding of their daily lives.
For Republicans, that leaves an uncomfortable truth: we made our bed, and now we have to lie in it. We had the opportunity to govern, and we bear responsibility for how that opportunity was handled.
My concern is that the next two years will bring more confrontation than accomplishment. With a lame-duck president and Democrats controlling Congress, getting meaningful legislation passed will be difficult. I hope both sides find reasons to work together, but I suspect we’re in for a frustrating stretch.
Democrats have been given a mandate to try to change course. They’ll also have to show that they can deliver something useful. Holding Republicans accountable comes with the responsibility to offer workable answers of their own.
That makes 2028 a pivotal election, particularly for the presidency. Republicans cannot assume that frustration with Democrats will automatically bring voters back. They need to earn that trust by listening, setting practical priorities, explaining their decisions honestly, and showing that they can govern with competence and empathy.
We don’t have to abandon our principles. But we do have to take a hard look at how we put them into practice—and whether people’s lives are actually improving as a result.
There’s a difference between telling people you’ve succeeded and showing them something that works better. There’s also a difference between speaking confidently and making people feel heard.
If Republicans hope to regain power anytime soon, they need to get their act together. The work starts with admitting why they lost.
Jim Baldassare – November 16, 2026



Comments